A Darlington man has been convicted of murdering his 14-year-old daughter, Scarlett, after stabbing her in the heart during what he claimed was a “play-fight” at their family home last summer.
Simon Vickers, 50, was found guilty of murder by a jury at Teesside Crown Court after deliberating for over 13 hours. The court heard harrowing details of how Scarlett sustained an 11cm stab wound to the chest in the kitchen of their home, a wound inflicted with a kitchen knife that proved fatal.
A Tragic Incident
The tragic event unfolded as Vickers prepared dinner while reportedly engaging in playful antics with his daughter. Scarlett’s mother, Sarah Hall, was the only other person in the room and described how their playful mood turned into a nightmare.
Ms Hall, who had been in a relationship with Vickers for 27 years, defended him in court, stating he loved their only child deeply and would never intentionally harm her. However, the prosecution presented compelling evidence that the fatal stab wound was not accidental.
Prosecution’s Case
Prosecutor Mark McKone KC told jurors:
The way the knife entered Scarlett’s chest required force. It is practically impossible for such a wound to be caused accidentally.
Dr Jennifer Bolton, a pathologist, supported this claim, stating the knife must have been deliberately held and inserted into Scarlett’s chest.
Although the prosecution acknowledged that Vickers appeared devastated by his daughter’s death, they argued that he provided a fabricated account to cover up his actions.
Family’s Grief and Community Mourning
Scarlett was a beloved Year 9 pupil at Haughton Academy in Darlington, remembered for her kindness and humour. Following her death, classmates paid tribute by releasing balloons in her memory.
A statement from Haughton Academy read:
Scarlett was always immaculately turned out, respectful, and polite. She had a great sense of humour and was popular with her friends. She will be greatly missed by everyone at the school.
The academy and the Education Village Academy Trust are providing support to students and staff during this difficult time.
Events Leading to the Tragedy
On the day of the incident, Vickers had consumed four glasses of wine and smoked cannabis while watching the Euros. According to Ms Hall, Scarlett had come downstairs to join the family, and they began playfully throwing grapes at one another.
The mood shifted when Ms Hall turned to serve spaghetti bolognese. Moments later, Scarlett exclaimed “ow,” and blood began pouring from her chest. Despite efforts to save her, Scarlett was pronounced dead at the scene.
A Divisive Verdict
The jury rejected Vickers’ claim that the stabbing was accidental, convicting him of murder by a majority verdict of 10-2. The alternative charge of manslaughter was dismissed.
Defence barrister Nicholas Lumley KC argued that Vickers had no intent to harm Scarlett, describing the incident as a tragic mistake.
Vickers will bear moral responsibility for his daughter’s death for the rest of his life,” Lumley stated.
The verdict left family members visibly stunned in the courtroom.
Sentencing Awaited
Simon Vickers will be sentenced on 10 February by Mr Justice Cotter. The conviction brings some closure to a devastating case but leaves a family and community grappling with an unimaginable loss.
Police Appeal
Authorities are urging families to prioritise safety in their homes and report any concerning incidents to prevent further tragedies.
For further updates, stay connected.
